House Democrats have nominated their party’s next leader, and it’s Brooklyn’s own Hakeem Jeffries. In January, he will likely become the next Speaker of the House and the first Black person to hold the role, which is second in line to the presidency.
Jeffries won the initial nomination vote by a landslide—251-to-11—with two Democrats abstaining.
But if the sentiment around this historic moment seems a little muted online, you can look no further than Jeffries’ critics on the Left who accused the establishment Democrat of being a little too establishment.
Several Democratic socialist lawmakers publicly came out against him over his moderate tendencies, while many online derided his longtime support of pro-Israel lobbying group, AIPAC.
“What I tried to impress upon Leader Jeffries is what we need in this moment right now is not just a caucus leader, but a leader of the Democratic Party,” said Rep. Don Leonard of Ohio on CNN, as reported by Time Magazine. “And that what I was seeing from the letter that he requested my support for his speakership was not indicative of the kind of things that my constituents need to see in order to put our faith that he is able to lead us.”
Leonard claimed in a social media video that senior party members told him “his life would become a ‘living hell’ if he didn’t back Jeffries,” wrote Time.
What does a Speaker even do?
At the same time, Representatives-elect Darializa Avila Chevalier and Clair Valdez of New York joined Chris Rabb of Pennsylvania, Colorado’s Melat Kiros, Adam Hamawy of New Jersey, Frederick Haynes of Texas, and Donavan McKinney of Michigan all came out against Jeffries despite finding some “meaningful progress” in speaking with him before the nomination vote.
“Whether on Medicare for All, stopping ICE terror, getting money out of politics, or ending the genocide in Gaza, our constituents sent us to Congress with a mandate on these issues,” the group wrote in a statement as reported by The Hill.
“We have worked to secure commitments from Leader Jeffries in good-faith conversations,” they said. “While we have seen meaningful progress, there is still work to be done to ensure that the direction our party takes this coming Congress reflects what our constituents are demanding of leadership.”
But while ideological debates are understandable and even encouraged, some of the criticism took on a racist bent or seemed rooted in a complete misunderstanding of what the Speaker does.
A largely thankless job for a cat-herding bean counter or consensus builder, being Speaker of the House is rooted in one’s ability to bring their party together, work across the aisle, and whip up votes. It’s not necessarily the best spot for an iconoclast, but a party loyalist who can keep members on task and win concessions.
‘Cautious and highly disciplined’
The previous Democratic speaker was Nancy Pelosi. Jeffries is her protege.
“Our message to the American people who are struggling in this failed economy is a simple one. We hear you, we see you, we feel you, and House Democrats are committed to making life better for you,” said Jeffries after his nomination, according to NPR.
“Mr. Jeffries, who in recent days met with almost all members and newly elected Democrats as he sought to wrap up his nomination with as little opposition as possible, is known for his cautious and highly disciplined style,” wrote Annie Karni for The New York Times.
Will being calm and measured work for Jeffries? If past is prologue, it couldn’t hurt. Especially when you consider the other Democrats whose names were floated for Speaker didn’t even want the job and voted for Jeffries.
“Jeffries effectively dared his critics to show that dissatisfaction with him was the same thing as support for somebody else. And the result demonstrated that, despite the bluster or posturing of some on cable news, the caucus was overwhelmingly united behind Jeffries and nobody else,” wrote Kaivan Shroff for MS NOW. “That’s a way to remove leverage and shut down a conversation that needlessly distracted from Democrats’ huge midterm wins.”
The House’s official vote to elect Jeffries, along with other leadership positions within the chamber, will take place on January 3rd next year.

